(no subject)
Jul. 3rd, 2008 01:15 pm ( The scientist who places his mind in the service of destructive force is the lowest form of life on Earth )
Say- just for example's sake- that you've spent your life striving with all your might to reach scientific enlightenment. Through observation, analysis, experimentation, trial, error, and above all else reason, to reach an understanding- however small, however limited- of the rules of the world and the larger universe. Say you believe that this is the most important thing you can do, this understanding. It's what you're good at. It's what you're suited for. This has been as much a part of you as breathing since the day your fumbling mind first understood that the noise you were hearing over and over referred to the noisemaker, and what had been babbling resolved itself into Mama.
You have been doing this for twenty-seven years now. This has been your very life. There've been other parts to it, to be sure- family, hobbies, the occasional friend, the occasional girl- but ever and always, this is the point it comes back to.
( happiness is that state achieved by the fullest expression of our values )
Now. It goes wrong.
It's one accident. Only one. Built on a hundred lesser accidents- the overloaded system, the unusual sample, the expectations imposed- but in the end it's all expressed in a single accident. But that accident made the world scream, and it brought in that which should not be. It happened because of observation and analysis and experimentation, and oh, yes, trial and error. So very much error. If there's reason in it anywhere, it's drowned in the flood, put aside in the name of survival, and maybe of trying to put things right...
Later come the questions. What happened and why and what now. And, on the heels of that, what have I done and what do I do now. Because when you saw that whether you meant it to or not, your very life had unforeseen consequences, you put everything aside and struck out at the world around you. The living signs of the universe's betrayal, the proofs that what you and others like you had done was too great a burden for the world to bear- those had to be destroyed. The men sent to put an end to the horrors and put you down at the same time- they had to be stopped. You might not have had it in you to put everything right, but you knew this much: you knew what was wrong, and you knew it couldn't be allowed to go any more wrong.
( morality ends where the gun begins )
That's what's held you up ever since. It may be the only thing that's held you up. Some nights you're not sure if you didn't die in the shadows underground after all, or in the black place of stone and winds from nowhere to nowhere. Even if you did, it doesn't matter, does it? You have too much to do for that to matter any more. One day your world will let you back in, and you'll have one last chance to fix the grand and terrible mistake that Science made. Someone has to. Maybe you can, if you're ready. Maybe you'll finally get to stop after that.
Problem: that's a grand, powerful, overarching goal. You're only human. You can't keep that in mind all the time. There are twenty-four hours in a day, and sixty minutes in an hour, and you still need to live from minute to minute and hour to hour, not in the overarching time of abstract goals and concepts. You have to eat, drink, act, sleep, talk, think. You make agreements, you take lessons, you learn from people, you act on their behalf. And sometimes the little things are enough to make you think: today I killed people, again- and then to know, on the heels of that thought, that you'll do it again if you have to, as often as you have to, if that's what it takes to see one more horrible wrong put right. Science has to redeem itself somehow. Where you come from, it tore the world apart and let the monsters in. Where Fury comes from, the monsters were already there. They're the ones using science to destroy everything else, one name and one bloodline at a time.
You might have died at Black Mesa, or in the black places of Xen, but science was your life and your love once. Whatever else it might cost you, you'll be damned if you let these bastards corrupt it any further.
( we will now see what happens when brute force meets force with a mind behind it )
Say- just for example's sake- that you've spent your life striving with all your might to reach scientific enlightenment. Through observation, analysis, experimentation, trial, error, and above all else reason, to reach an understanding- however small, however limited- of the rules of the world and the larger universe. Say you believe that this is the most important thing you can do, this understanding. It's what you're good at. It's what you're suited for. This has been as much a part of you as breathing since the day your fumbling mind first understood that the noise you were hearing over and over referred to the noisemaker, and what had been babbling resolved itself into Mama.
You have been doing this for twenty-seven years now. This has been your very life. There've been other parts to it, to be sure- family, hobbies, the occasional friend, the occasional girl- but ever and always, this is the point it comes back to.
( happiness is that state achieved by the fullest expression of our values )
Now. It goes wrong.
It's one accident. Only one. Built on a hundred lesser accidents- the overloaded system, the unusual sample, the expectations imposed- but in the end it's all expressed in a single accident. But that accident made the world scream, and it brought in that which should not be. It happened because of observation and analysis and experimentation, and oh, yes, trial and error. So very much error. If there's reason in it anywhere, it's drowned in the flood, put aside in the name of survival, and maybe of trying to put things right...
Later come the questions. What happened and why and what now. And, on the heels of that, what have I done and what do I do now. Because when you saw that whether you meant it to or not, your very life had unforeseen consequences, you put everything aside and struck out at the world around you. The living signs of the universe's betrayal, the proofs that what you and others like you had done was too great a burden for the world to bear- those had to be destroyed. The men sent to put an end to the horrors and put you down at the same time- they had to be stopped. You might not have had it in you to put everything right, but you knew this much: you knew what was wrong, and you knew it couldn't be allowed to go any more wrong.
( morality ends where the gun begins )
That's what's held you up ever since. It may be the only thing that's held you up. Some nights you're not sure if you didn't die in the shadows underground after all, or in the black place of stone and winds from nowhere to nowhere. Even if you did, it doesn't matter, does it? You have too much to do for that to matter any more. One day your world will let you back in, and you'll have one last chance to fix the grand and terrible mistake that Science made. Someone has to. Maybe you can, if you're ready. Maybe you'll finally get to stop after that.
Problem: that's a grand, powerful, overarching goal. You're only human. You can't keep that in mind all the time. There are twenty-four hours in a day, and sixty minutes in an hour, and you still need to live from minute to minute and hour to hour, not in the overarching time of abstract goals and concepts. You have to eat, drink, act, sleep, talk, think. You make agreements, you take lessons, you learn from people, you act on their behalf. And sometimes the little things are enough to make you think: today I killed people, again- and then to know, on the heels of that thought, that you'll do it again if you have to, as often as you have to, if that's what it takes to see one more horrible wrong put right. Science has to redeem itself somehow. Where you come from, it tore the world apart and let the monsters in. Where Fury comes from, the monsters were already there. They're the ones using science to destroy everything else, one name and one bloodline at a time.
You might have died at Black Mesa, or in the black places of Xen, but science was your life and your love once. Whatever else it might cost you, you'll be damned if you let these bastards corrupt it any further.
( we will now see what happens when brute force meets force with a mind behind it )